Skip to content
100% Certified & Lab-Tested Gemstones – Shop with Confidence.
100% Certified & Lab-Tested Gemstones – Shop with Confidence.
Why Astrologers Recommend Different Stones for the Same Problem

Why Astrologers Recommend Different Stones for the Same Problem

Astrological gemstones have been utilized for a long time to aid in achieving the balance of energy, encourage prosperity, and assist people to overcome obstacles in their lives. However, one of the most frequent queries people are:

"Why does different Astrologers advocate different stones for the same problem?"

For instance, a person experiencing career difficulties might be urged to put on Yellow Sapphire by one Astrologer, Emerald by another and Blue Sapphire by another. For marital bliss, financial wealth, peace and health or confidence gemstones can be suggested from astrologer-to-astrologer.

Why is this happening?

Is it confusion or perhaps there is a more fundamental motive behind these diverse suggestions?

In this thorough guide, we'll examine the factors that lead to different gemstone suggestions as well as how astrologers study charts in relation to substitutes and how planetary strengths are a factor and how online marketplaces such as GemsRoot can help you select authentic precious stones with confidence.

1. Each Birth Chart is Unique, Even if the problem appears similar

Two people could be facing the same problem - career decline and delayed marriage, or financial difficulties, but their the planetary positions may not be identical.

Astrologers examine:

  • Planet positions

  • Planet force

  • House combinations

  • Dasha (current planetary period)

  • Antardasha (sub-period)

  • Planetary aspects

  • Exaltation and debilitation

  • Combustion effects

  • Nakshatra placements

Even if the issue appears similar but the the root of the issue is different.

Example

  • One person may require the Yellow Sapphire (Pukhraj) to strengthen Jupiter for growth in their career.

  • Another might require an Emerald (Panna) to balance Mercury and enhance communication.

  • Another might require blue Sapphire (Neelam) to activate Saturn for discipline and to open up opportunities.

Similar problem, but different astrological root.

2. Astrologers Utilize Multiple Methods of Interpretation

Different astrologers have different astrological styles or branches. the astrology field, including:

  • Vedic Astrology

  • KP Astrology

  • Lal Kitab

  • Nadi Astrology

  • Parashari System

  • Jaimini System

  • Gemstone Therapy Based Astrology

Each program gives different gemstone suggestions even when dealing with the same issue.

For instance:

In Parashari Astrology the idea of strengthening weak planets might be recommended.
In KP Astrology, lessening negative influences through substitutes could be suggested.

Therefore, stones vary based on the technique used.

3. Primary Gemstones as opposed to Uparatnas (Substitute Stones)

Every planet is home to:

  • A principal gemstone

  • A substitute gemstone (Uparatna)

  • A semi-precious stone that supports a semi-precious

This allows for a range of possibilities.

Primarily High-Quality Gemstones (Navratna)

Uparatnas (Substitutes)

  • Sun - Garnet

  • Moon - Moonstone

  • Mars - Carnelian

  • Mercury - Peridot

  • Jupiter - Citrine

  • Venus White Topaz

  • Saturn - Amethyst

  • Rahu - Ceylon Gomed substitutes

  • Ketu Chysoberyl alternative

Astrologers may suggest an main stone while another could suggest an alternative alternative depending on:

  • Budget

  • Sensitivity

  • Planet force

  • Wearing a comfortable outfit

  • Metals and metal preferences

  • Risk tolerance

4. Strong Stones & Safer Alternatives

Gemstones that are precious like Blue Sapphire, Emerald, Ruby along with Yellow Sapphire are powerful. If they are worn improperly they can result in:

  • Emotional imbalance

  • Excessive energy

  • Sudden life shifts

  • Negative reactions

  • Health discomfort

For safety reasons Astrologers may suggest gentler alternatives.

Example

If Saturn needs to be balanced, but the individual has sensitivity to Blue Sapphire, they might be advised wearing Amethyst rather.

Same issue, Stones with different intensity.

5. Boost or Balance Planetary Energy

This is one of the reasons why gemstone recommendations differ.

Approach 1: Strengthening a weak Planet

If an earth planet is weak but good, astrologers help will strengthen it by:

  • Emerald for Mercury

  • Yellow Sapphire is used for Jupiter

  • Ruby for Sun

Approach 2: Decrease a Planet that is Malefic

If a planet's activity is excessive or dangerous, astrologers may suggest:

  • Beware of primary stones

  • Substitutes to wear

  • Wearing neutral stones

Example

If the Moon is making you emotionally unstable:

  • Astrologers may suggest pearl to help stabilize it.

  • Another option is Moonstone to aid in gentle healing.

Same issue, Different strategy.

6. Different Problems Can be Linked to Planets of Different Kind

Astrology is rarely the sole reason for an issue in your life.

The same issue can be experienced by the different people could be affected by different astrological factors.

Example Wedding Delay

People A - Jupiter is weak. Yellow Sapphire

Person B - Venus is suffering. Diamond

Person C - Mars is making Mangalik problems. Red Coral

Person D - Saturn is causing delays to the seventh house. Blue Sapphire

Astrologers suggest gemstones that are based on the planet that is causing the issue as well as the problem.

7. Birth Chart Strength Changes Over Time (Dasha & Transit)

Planetary times (Dashas) along with transits could alter the orbit of the planet, causing the issue.

Example

In Mercury Dasha - Emerald becomes essential

During Jupiter Dasha - Yellow Sapphire can be beneficial

During Saturn Dasha - Blue Sapphire can be prescribed

Hence, timing changes gemstone advice.

8. Personal Preferences & Past Experience

Some people are more responsive to certain stones because of:

  • Chemical makeup of the skin

  • Aura compatibility

  • Previous gemstone results

  • Comfort for the soul

  • Personal energy field

Astrologers are aware of this and make adjustments to their suggestions.

So, two people with the same problem may get completely different suggestions for gemstones.

9. Natural vs Treated Gemstones

If someone is unable to pay for an untreated, natural precious stone, such as:

  • Emerald

  • Blue Sapphire

  • Ruby

  • Diamond

  • Yellow Sapphire

Astrologers can recommend a top-quality alternative. This ensures that the client still receives the benefits of astrology within the budget.

10. It Also Depends on the Jewelry You Wish to Wear

Different stones are suitable to various types of jewelry.

Certain astrologers suggest stones based on person's personal preferences.

  • Rings are stronger, direct contact
  • Pendants are safer for energy sensitive people
  • Bracelets with moderate energy
  • Lockets with mild vibration

If the individual is just looking for an ornamental pendant The astrologer might suggest the use of a more gentle alternative instead of an strong principal stone.

11. The Authenticity and Source Plays A Big Role Why GemsRoot is Important

One reason that gemstone advice differs is the dearth of genuine stones available in markets.

Some astrologers prefer stones that are sourced from reliable platforms such as GemsRoot due to:

  • They offer only 100 percent natural, certified gems.

  • Every precious stone, including Ruby, Emerald, Yellow Sapphire, Blue Sapphire, Diamond, Pearl, Coral, Cat's Eye Hessonite and more are verified.

  • High definition videos with clear information assist astrologers in guiding clients precisely.

  • Prices are clear and based on purity the source and treatment.

  • They also provide astrological guidance as well as authentic reports.

A gemstone that is certified always provides more secure and better outcomes.

12. Why Different Gemstones to Solve the Same Problem?

  • Since every birth chart is unique, every one of them is
  • Different astrologers use different techniques
  • Primary and substitute gemstones as well as their respective substitutes exist
  • Stone strength varies, and alternative options that are safer could be suggested
  • Some suggest strengthening the planets, while others suggest reducing them.
  • Different planets may be responsible for the same problem.
  • Transits and Dashas change the recommendations
  • Budget preferences, budget, and sensitivity are important.
  • Natural gemstone availability affects choice
  • Stone type influences jewelry selection

This is the reason astrology is not a universal system. It is specific and tailored to your needs and energy.

13. Conclusion

The gemstone you wear carries intent, energy and the ability to bring about change within your own life. No matter what it is, Emerald for your intellect, Yellow Sapphire for prosperity, Ruby for confidence, Blue Sapphire for discipline, or Diamond for luxurious and love Your stone must be selected with guidance and a sense of authenticity.

GemsRoot can help you make the right decision with:

  • Natural Certified gemstones

  • HD video previews

  • Transparency in pricing and the source

  • Professional astrological advice

  • A variety of precious stones to suit every budget

Choose your gemstone with focus, clarity and a high-quality that you can trust.

Next article Top 10 Aries Birthstone: Complete Guide to the Best Gemstones